Past is Present, presented by Sumter Museum: Scott Estep on displaying stories on the walls, history on the plate at J. O Grady's

Posted

Sumter and sports. It's hard to talk about one without the other. Around here, ballgames raised just as many kids as classrooms did. Folks remember who threw the winning pass in 1988 like it happened last night and will tell you about it over a burger and a cold beer without missing a beat.

That kind of remembering - that honoring - is what Scott Estep is all about. At J. O'Gradys, the walls, adorned with decades of greatness, are for more than just holding up the pub-style burger joint. They're an ode to Friday night legends and hometown kids who made it big. To coaches who gave up their afternoons for little more than a stipend and a dream. To the names we didn't always know and the ones we could never forget.

Sports have been Estep's passion since he was a toddler in Sumter and well into his teenage years - if it involved making plays, scoring points and being showered in cheers and the occasional Gatorade, then there was a jersey and a number associated with his name. But his father instilled in him the value of not only knowing where to find the turf, but also knowing where you come from.

"He said, 'Kenny, you need to read the [news]paper, front to back - obituaries, yard sales, sports, business, everything.' I'm like, 'Well, why's that, Pop?' 'Well, you need to do it because no matter who you run into, there'll be something you can converse with,'" he recalled. "It was the best piece of advice."

And he took that advice to heart. Over the years, through the pages of The Sumter Item, Estep learned about government meetings, community happenings and where to find the best secondhand treasures across the county. Throughout his reading, he'd spot a few familiar names and faces.

Bobby Richardson. Freddie Solomon. Keith West. Dexter Davis. Bobby Baker. Art Baker. Byron Kenny. Tom Lewis - just to name a few.

They were names that Sumter knew well and treasured greatly. Names he grew up hearing called alongside his as they braved the Friday night lights. Names that coached greats on how to be great. Names that left home for the big leagues and returned home with their legacy and willingness to share lessons. Names that would follow him into adulthood and into his business.

The brick building nestled on the corner of 5 S. Main St. has housed many businesses, some that were "before Main Street's time," Estep said. When he was approached about trying his hand at business, he wanted to make it meaningful.

Estep had many mentors growing up, one being his former USC Sumter professor Jack Doyle. His smile grew as he reminisced on Doyle's ability to paint a picture with words, telling stories that would capture your heart and your imagination. Post-graduation, the two developed a rapport, sharing great stories of an Irish pub named O' Gradys being "the greatest bar" - told by Doyle in an Irish accent, with greater laughs and the greatest life lessons. Which is why after Doyle developed dementia, passing away sometime later, Estep wanted to keep the memory of such a brilliant mind alive.

He opened J. O'Gradys - the J being for Jack. Styled after an Irish pub, the space was renovated by Estep to allow customers to easily flow through. If they wanted to lounge in a booth or be alert at a table? They could take their pick. They wanted to make a break for the bar at half time? There was ample space to do so. Menu items were named after local folks who left their mark on the community through service and sacrifice - be it Coach Baker's Taco Salad and Sammy's Way burger or Dexter's Seared Yellowfin Salad or the BR-K55 Fall Classic, named after Bobby Richardson's K-55 model bat.

But J. O'Gradys is far more than a restaurant. A quick glance at any wall will show that it's a living, breathing museum of Sumter's sports history, housing Sumter County Sports Hall of Fame.

As mentioned, sports is Estep's passion, and he had a sports collection to prove it. Anything sports related he could get his hands on, especially that of baseball center fielder Mickey Mantle, he would add to his personal collection. However, he realized he couldn't collect everything, deciding to switch gears and focus on finding memorabilia of the folks right here at home.

The search for these items was much harder. You wouldn't find Bobby Richardson's Edmunds High School baseball jersey lying around at a flea market or Freddie Solomon's 49ers cleats at a secondhand store. Those items were rare finds. Those items were gifts, delivered to Estep personally.

He remembers the day he arrived home to see an all-too-familiar brown Piggly Wiggly bag sitting on his doorstep. Snatching it up before the family dog could get ahold of it, the feel of the heavy jersey in his hands was an experience. He immediately called "Mr. Richardson," who over time had become a close friend and mentor - the formal nickname is a result of Estep's Southern upbringing - to see if he was the anonymous gift giver.

"No, Scotty, I didn't drop that jersey off at the house," Estep was told. He was puzzled. Who could it have been?

Joseph Cannarella Jr., former coach at Sumter School District and Sumter Sports Hall of Fame inductee, pulled up in his white Porsche alongside Estep on a morning walk one day.

"'You get that package I left you?'" Estep recalled the question. "I'm like, 'That was you.'"

These items - these bookmarks of monumental moments and legendary figures in our county's history - hold memories. And Estep felt there would be no better place to display them than along the walls of J. O'Gradys. A place where they can jog memories of the good old days and jump start conversations of what Sumter means to you, me and the next person. Where they can be a physical reminder of what it means to leave a legacy, one etched in home runs, touchdowns and community involvement no matter how many decades removed one may be from the glory days. Where generations can bond over stories of athletes who ventured to big cities and still chose to come back to Sumter's green pastures.

"Sumter seems to rally behind its own. It doesn't matter what demographic you come from. If you're a baseball player, you might impersonate Mr. Richardson, right? If you're playing football out in the yard, catching passes - I'm Freddie Solomon. I think that's what's unique about our town," Estep expressed. "We rally around all of them, no matter who you are."

Today, alongside the black-and-white photos of local greats, you'll find a Funko Pop of Crestwood Knight and Memphis Grizzly Ja Morant or the jersey of Sumter High Gamecock and Pittsburgh Steelers punter Pressley Harvin III. As you wait for a cold drink at the bar, you can study the glove of Arizona Diamondbacks pitcher Jordan Montgomery or Sacramento Athletics pitcher J.P. Sears. For people in far-off places, these names are written in the stars. For friends, family, classmates and coaches, these names are written in classroom pranks, afternoon hangouts, big wins and heartfelt hugs.

Which is why for Estep, collecting and displaying them is more for the community connection than his showboating his ability to acquire such items. The restaurant and Estep's reverence serve as reminders of how local legends, whether known or forgotten, deserve their due.

When one of Sumter's own makes it big - or quietly pours back into the community - there's always a place for them on the wall, in the stories and in the hearts of people who feel "That's one of ours."


x